Part III · 2014–2018

Modi's First Term

Muslims and other religious minorities in India have always been harmed by the rhetoric of far-right ideologies, but the rise of the Bharatiya Janata Party to national prominence ushered in an era where Hindutva finds its strongholds in core democratic institutions: the law, judiciary, electorate, and media. Today, under the rule of Prime Minister Narendra Modi, Indian Muslims are relegated to second class citizenry due to countless discriminatory measures. Many of these are signed into law, while others are uncodified yet equally marginalizing. Muslims and other religious and caste minorities face barriers to obtaining basic civil rights but are also regular targets of violence, dispossession, and hateful rhetoric.

Since the Bharatiya Janata Party won a majority of legislative seats in the 2014 elections, Muslim representation in Parliament has fallen to 5%. This electoral capture was pivotal to reshaping public opinion towards religious minorities and gave the BJP an executive platform for its objective of a Hindu majoritarian state.

Democratic Institutions Held Captive Under BJP-Led Government

The intersection of BJP mainstream politics with the press, law enforcement, and courts has weaponized these once neutral pillars of society — orchestrating anti-Muslim prejudices. According to Ballard Brief, a majority of religion-based hate crimes (documented between 2009 to 2019) coincided with the BJP electoral victories of 2014. Political hate speech has become a norm — shooting up by 500% between 2014 and 2018 during Modi's first term as prime minister.

Many law enforcement officers reflect prejudiced views in policing practices and do not extend the same protection to Muslim victims as they do others. This is particularly evident during historic episodes of communal violence, in which a conflict involves two or more social groups. During the 2020 New Delhi protests to the controversial Citizenship Amendment Act (CAA) officials reportedly did not intervene to stop the violent actions of Hindu mobs, while Muslim protestors were arrested in disproportionate numbers.

Even when Muslim victims manage to file complaints with the police, the names of complicit law enforcement members and individuals affiliated with the BJP are often omitted.

Although vigilante and paramilitary violence have constituted much of these hate crimes, municipal institutions have also been instrumental to anti-Muslim violence and repression. The practice of punitive demolitions, in which accusations of encroachment or the absence of a permit, are used to procure demolition orders for Muslim properties.

In India's press, independent media face growing censorship as many partisan news organizations no longer practice watchdog journalism, but act as mouthpieces for the BJP. Popular channels like Asianet News Network, News18, and Zee News are directly overseen or consolidated under franchises owned by BJP members while growing financial pressures in the news industry pressure networks to carry sponsored content.

Continue Reading

Go back to Part II of Hindutva: A Timeline, or explore more resources on Hindutva and the Indian Muslim experience.